Just a great, creamy, traditional Coleslaw recipe with a terrific homemade Coleslaw dressing. Everything you want, none of the unnecessary extras. A staple for that’s even better the next day!
For a healthier version with no mayo, make this Cole slaw with a Creamy Yogurt Coleslaw Dressing (it’s so good!) OR try the RecipeTin No Mayo Coleslaw.
Coleslaw recipe in a snap
- Type of cabbage for Coleslaw – green cabbage is the classic. Red cabbage is great too (but will bleed colour slightly), savoy and Napa cabbage can also be used.
- How long does Coleslaw last? Up to 5 days in the fridge.
- What’s in Coleslaw Dressing? Mayonnaise, sour cream or yogurt, vinegar, mustard, celery salt and sugar.
- Why does my Coleslaw get watery? Because you didn’t use enough dressing. The Dressing extracts water from the cabbage which thins the dressing. You need to start with plenty of thick Coleslaw Dressing which is then thinned out when the cabbage wilts and leaches water.
- How much Coleslaw to make per person? 1/2 a head of cabbage will make enough for 10 people as a side for a meal, or 15 people at a large gathering with plenty of other food on the buffet. So for 100 people, you will need 5 heads of cabbage as a side for a meal, or 3 1/2 heads as part of a larger buffet.
A great Coleslaw doesn’t need a ton of ingredients.
All you need is cabbage, carrot and a terrific Coleslaw dressing for this summertime classic. Along with Macaroni Salad and Caprese Salad, this is the salad we take to gatherings, that we lay out on buffets – because we know it’s a sure thing!
It lasts for days in the fridge so we have a great standby side for dinners and quick additions to lunchboxes. A traditional Coleslaw recipe is a classic that will never go out of fashion!
Coleslaw dressing
I’m a firm believer that Coleslaw should be JUICY. Just like it’s served up at KFC and other popular takeout chains. And juicy means plenty of dressing!
I like BUT if you just load up your dressing with tons of mayo, it weighs it down with too much fat, making the Cole slaw excessively rich and soaking the cabbage to the point of being soggy mush.
So I like to make plenty of dressing with a combination of both mayonnaise and sour cream, plus mustard and celery salt for flavour, and vinegar to cut through the richness.
Why does my Coleslaw get watery?
Most likely because you are not using enough dressing. Coleslaw is meant to be set aside to wilt before serving, during which time water is extracted from the cabbage which thins the dressing.
So you need to ensure there’s enough Dressing otherwise your Coleslaw becomes watery!
Key Tip: Give it time
To achieve that perfect Coleslaw texture, it needs time to soften so you don’t have stiff prints of cabbage poking out all over the place. At least 20 minutes, better at 2 hours or overnight.
The salt and sugar in the dressing draws out the moisture from the cabbage, thinning out the rich dressing and making the Coleslaw ultra juicy, as well as giving time for the flavours to meld.
Serve this with BBQ Pulled Pork (make sliders!), BBQ Brisket or these terrific sticky Country-Style Chicken Thighs with a side of steamed corn for a summer cookout indoors! – Nagi x
MORE SUMMER SALADS to take to gatherings
Pearl Couscous Salad <– personal fave!
Wild Rice Salad <– reader fave!
Browse all Pasta Salads and Rice Salad
WATCH HOW TO MAKE IT
Hungry for more? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow along on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all of the latest updates.
Coleslaw
Ingredients
- 7 cups green cabbage , finely shredded (Note 1)
- 1 medium carrot , shredded (1 1/2 cups)
Dressing
- 1/2 cup Hellman’s mayonnaise (or other whole egg mayo)
- 1/2 cup sour cream or yoghurt, full fat is best
- 1 1/2 tbsp apple cider vinegar (or sub with white wine vinegar)
- 2 tsp Dijon mustard
- 2 tbsp white sugar
- 3/4 tsp celery salt
- 1/4 tso black pepper
Instructions
- Mix Dressing ingredients together.
- Place cabbage and carrot in a bowl. Pour over Dressing, toss well. Set aside for at least 20 minutes before serving, preferably 2 hours – this will make the cabbage go limp as it should, and also draw moisture out of the cabbage and carrot to thin out the dressing. Overnight is even better!
- Toss well before serving.
Recipe Notes:
Add chopped or sliced onions
Add shallots/scallions finely sliced on the diagonal
Swap out some of the green cabbage for red cabbage (love the colour)
Granny smith apples cut into batons (YUM that would be fantastic!) 4. Nutrition per serving, assuming 8 servings.
Nutrition Information:
LIFE OF DOZER
Flashback: when he was a puppy and couldn’t get down stairs….
Having trouble finding celery salt- any subs?
Use celery seed if you can find it. Celery salt is just salt mixed with celery seed, so use the seed and a pinch more salt. (Pro-tip: grind the celery seed if you have a mortar and pestle.) BTW celery seed also goes great in potato salad, roasted potatoes, or anywhere you want a zing of celery flavour!
Go to Bin Inn, the bulk buy store.
Hi Edwina, just leave it out if you’re having trouble finding it 🙂 N x
Nagi ❤️
Made this for the 2nd time today!!! Sooooo easy peasy! I added just a little bit of onion for flavor … yum 😋 My Dozer (Oreo) loves to eat the carrots 🥕 when I’m preparing the coleslaw. I love all your recipes
I made this with leftover pizza today. Such a great recipe 🙂
The coelslaw dressing is amazing!! So light and creamy! Family loved it with your sticky grilled chicken!! Amazzzing!!! Thanks Nagi for another great receipe👍👍
Hi Nagi. I love all your recipes and your coleslaw is amazing. I would love to know where you purchased that slicer you used to Julianne the carrots. Hugs to you and Dozer.
Hi Heather, this mandoline was purchased from a local store – it was fairly inexpensive, you can find them online and range in price! N x
Thank you for taking the time to reply.💝🧑🍳
Hi Nagi! Can this be made with Savoy cabbage?
Apologies Nagi! I just found the answer to my question in your post! I didn’t read it carefully enough 🙂
Your dressing recipe is so good! I have tried it yesterday with my homemade sweetened yoghurt and less white sugar. The result was sensational!
Thank you very much, Nagi! I love your style of cooking and will definely take more time to explore your recipes. Have a nice weekend!
Nagi, Thanks so much for sharing! Made this with the Slow Cooker BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich and it was soooo good!! The coleslaw definitely tastes better and better if you can stand to wait till the next day!
Hi Chris, I 100% agree – the flavour is so much better the next day! N x
Hi, Nagi and Dozer! My husband and I loved the slaw. We live in Charleston SC USA and drove out Wadmalaw which is an coastal isaland and bought beautiful huge shrimp off the boat that were caught today! This slaw was a great dish to serve with the shrimp. TY!
That sounds divine Martha!! N x
Just love your recipes here in NZ, love following dozer too. Thankyou for your hard work through lock down, your butter chicken and kneadless rolls were a winner
Just wondering what is TSO Black pepper? Looks like it is a sauce made up of lots of things when i google it but it isn’t clear. Thanks!
Hi Gillian – that should be tsp – for teaspoon. Will correct it now! N x
Thank you so much. I finally found a coleslaw recipe that is just like KFC and so easy to make. I got a small head of fresh cabbage from a local farmers market and made this so quickly before the rest of dinner. It was so good I wish I made the whole head of cabbage. I used the mayonnaise- of course Hellman’s and sour cream, which I thick made the dressing and the apple cider vinegar. I got some coleslaw seasoning from my local Amish store. And now I will never have to buy coleslaw again! Thank you so much for your recipes.
Thank you so much. I finally found a coleslaw recipe that is just like KFC and so easy to make. I got a small head of fresh cabbage from a local farmers market and made this so quickly before the rest of dinner. It was so good I wish I made the whole head of cabbage. I used the mayonnaise- of course Hellman’s and sour cream, which I thick made the dressing and the apple cider vinegar. I got some coleslaw seasoning from my local Amish store. And now I will never have to buy coleslaw again! Thank you so much for your recipes.
Hi Naji,
This is the best coleslaw we’ve ever tasted. It’s absolutely fantastic. I add the zest of a lemon for a bit of zing and use the best greek yogurt to make sure that we get the best out this amzaing recipie of yours. Thank you:))
I made French dip and needed a side. I had a half head of red and green cabbage from another recipe, so I made this coleslaw and even my picky wife loved it. 5 stars.
Sounds delicious Mike!! N x
Seriously delicious coleslaw…added corn, shallots and batons of pink lady apple to the slaw mix….the dressing is to die for thanks Nagi another winner
Sounds fabulous Kym! N x
Fabulous!
Made it a couple of times, last time yesterday, and it was always a success! I love the contrast between the sharp taste of mustard and the sweetness from sugar. Yesterday I had many friends over, I made a large bowl that was finished within minutes with multiple people giving huge compliments 👌
Before trying this, I must admit I would have said who needs a recipe for coleslaw… it’s just carrot, cabbage and mayo! Boy was I wrong… This is in another league! I will never make it any other way again. Thank you Nagi! Ps did this with the BBQ beef brisket… delish 🙂
Oh my gosh so light and delicious and those in my fam who never liked heavy slaw before just loved this lighter version yum yum
I’m so glad it was a hit Caron! N x
Hi Nagi, thank you so much! This is the best coleslaw recipe I have ever tried. I never leave comments, this is the first. This was spot on! No changes!
Great JoAnn! N x